Getting Tasted and reviewed a whopping 12 milkshakes across the town, I'm able to confidently declare that I've narrowed down the final word contenders to the title from the best milkshake in NYC. Indeed, this is probably the town’s oldest restaurants and it might are the primary restaurant in town https://www.google.com/maps/d/viewer?mid=1JGWiPHXUgWF9X3Ay6DmFolxdun4PGug